Dancing in Damascus

Sounds like a book which would draw one back to the heart of the revolution.

P U L S E

wissamThis review of miriam cooke’s new book was published at the Guardian.

Syria’s revolution triggered a volcano of long-repressed thought and emotion in cultural as well as political form. Independent newspapers and radio stations blossomed alongside popular poetry and street graffiti. This is a story largely untold in the West. Who knew, for instance, of the full houses, despite continuous bombardment, during Aleppo’s December 2013 theatre festival?

“Dancing in Damascus” by Arabist and critic miriam cooke (so she writes her name, uncapitalised) aims to fill the gap, surveying responses in various genres to revolution, repression, war and exile.

Dancing is construed both as metaphor for collective solidarity and debate – as Emma Goldman said, “If I can’t dance, it isn’t my revolution” – and as literal practice. At protests, Levantine dabke was elevated from ‘folklore’ to radical street-level defiance, just as popular songs were transformed into revolutionary anthems.

Cooke’s…

View original post 669 more words

Intelligence official killed in bomb blast, Kafr Sousa, S.W. Damascus, Thursday, possibly on US sanctions list published the same day (12th).

Al Arabiya names the individual as “Colonel Haider” here. If the same man, the US Treasury calls him, on a new sanctions list, published on Thursday, 12th, Colonel Zuhayr Haydar, here. An easier-to-read list, containing his name, can be found here. (The term “NPWMD” means apparently “Weapons of Mass Destruction Proliferators”.) That list should be examined side by side with this list here, which is in Arabic, as can be seen. It was linked to in this Facebook post, dated 13th August 2012 (over four years ago). Some names, including maybe Haydar/Haider’s, in the Arabic list correlate with the Treasury list. My weak Arabic translation facility identified in fact four possible matches, after a quick look (number in Arabic list in bold, Treasury entry following), as follows:

No 7 on Arabic list: ABBAS, Ghassan; DOB 10 Mar 1960; Scientific Studies and Research Center Brigadier General (individual) [NPWMD] (Linked To: SCIENTIFIC STUDIES AND RESEARCH CENTER).

No 6 on Arabic list: BILAL, Muhammad Nafi (a.k.a. BILAL, Muhammad), Syria; DOB 25 May 1971; alt. DOB 1971; Gender Male; Syrian Air Force Intelligence Colonel (individual) [SYRIA] (Linked To: SYRIAN AIR FORCE INTELLIGENCE).

No 5 or 28 on Arabic list: HAYDAR, Zuhayr; DOB 18 Dec 1965; Scientific Studies and Research Center Colonel (individual) [NPWMD] (Linked To: SCIENTIFIC STUDIES AND RESEARCH CENTER).

No 15  on Arabic list: IBRAHIM, Muhammad; DOB 05 Aug 1964; Brigadier General (individual) [SYRIA] (Linked To: SYRIAN AIR FORCE).

There may of course be other matches. However, only an Arabic speaker, who also knows English, will find them in useful time. There is no question though that there is an element of correlation.

“Too late!” she cried, and waved her wooden leg.

The above is a well-known expression of the futility of approaching something in order to fix it after the thing has ceased to exist. These new sanctions look like another last-minute positive action in Syria by the Obama team, to dress up his exit from the stage as a man of action – except that someone else seems to be beating him to it, not similarly by sanctioning Assad’s bad guys but by simply bumping them off… I speak not disrespectfully of the dead, and so will not labour this point. But, it does look like that.

We’re in a news vacuum right now. We must wait and see.

NB: All dates local to the relevant website, depending on its settings.

Interesting article from Bilal Abdul Kareem concerning possible US airstrike on Sarmada, Idlib.

Chaos In Wake Of Syria Ceasefire

(Source unknown)

“Chaos continued to rein in war torn Syria yesterday.  As rebel groups issued a statement declaring a freeze in negotiations, a purported US airstrike devastated a Jabha Fath Sham headquarters in the north Syrian town of Sarmada yesterday.

“The groups have cited continued violations of the ceasefire as regime troops continue to try and advance on the strategic area of Wadi Barada.”

Full article

I added a comment which may be awaiting moderation for several days, so here it is:

Sarmada (سرمدا) is in the midst of a cluster of IDP camps, one of them Al-Kamoneh (الكمونة)* which lies on a hillside a couple of miles to the south-east of the town and was bombed or shelled in early May, the aggressor unclear. Turkey, according to several TRT World reports just before Christmas, has been busy in that camp and others erecting more accommodation, the charity IHH
heavily involved – IHH were greeting evacuees right up next to government positions in Aleppo West during the evacuation, so appear to be roaming freely in Idlib and western Aleppo governorates (doing good work, one should add). So, any bombing operations in or on the approaches to Sarmada will be close to IDP concentrations. Obama seems to be thrashing about somewhat during his last days in office: knifing Israel at the UN, trying to skewer Trump through hacking allegations, being examples. So, one simply doesn’t know what chaotic notions may be in his head about Syria, where his entire policy in that country – if policy is the word – is in the process of being rendered an empty sham by Russia and Turkey between them. Whoever bombed Sarmada would have needed pinpoint intelligence and accuracy to justify an attack in the midst of an area riddled with IDP camps and, since mid-December, Turkish charity workers and their equipment. If JFS are on the ground in that area, Turkey can talk to them, which means also that Russia can, through Turkey. They can be steered that way. The odd man out is the US. Unpredictable behaviour from that quarter seems to fit. Whatever Turkey’s and Russia’s plans are, it will suit Obama to try to scupper them, through his influence with Kurdish militants, through use of his air force or even through some dirty deal or other with Daesh or – the prime monster amongst all or any of them – Assad. Roll on January 20th.

*Name derives from cumin, though I am not certain the camp itself bears this name, even if it is generally referred to by it. I did a small study of that camp here: http://bit.ly/alkamoneh.

Comment is based more on gut instinct than actual research as unfortunately I have had to pull away from close examination of Syrian affairs due to the time involved, partly, but also because the evolving dynamics there are beginning to speak for themselves.

Dietrich Bonhoeffer, anti-Nazi dissident and plotter, who, for his courage and virtue, paid with his life, aged 39 – is Assad Syria’s Hitler?

bundesarchiv_bild_146-1987-074-16_dietrich_bonhoeffer

Bonhoeffer

New window

Dietrich Bonhoeffer (4th February 1906 – 9th April 1945) was a German Lutheran pastor, theologian and anti-Nazi dissident – and a writer. A few months before his arrest in 1943, he sent an essay to friends, entitled “After 10 Years”, in which he analysed his and their resistance to the rise of evil, in the person of Hitler, the nature of that evil and its various effects on men. So much of what he wrote, then, knits also into the nature of the wickedness of Assad, now, and its effects, that I am transcribing Bonhoeffer’s piece here, in a series of pictures, together with a few bits of text extracted as text and my own comments.

1

1.

New window

Our losses have been great and immeasurable, but time has not been lost.

The Syrian revolution has suffered terribly too, these last five, if not 10, years – the revolution, and Syria herself.

*****

2

2.

New window

… something new was emerging that could not be seen in the existing alternatives.

Despite no doubt a sense at times of hopelessness and bewilderment amongst revolutionaries, something new is emerging in Syria, because it must. No peace can exist in that country with Assad in power. No rational person, Russian, Turk or Syrian, can think otherwise.

*****

3

3.

New window

4

4.

New window

5

5.

New window

The great masquerade of evil has played havoc with all our ethical concepts. For evil to appear disguised as light, charity, historical necessity, or social justice is quite bewildering…

Evil approaches… in so many respectable and seductive disguises…

[A man] will assent to what is bad so as to ward off something worse, and in doing so he will no longer be able to realise that the worse, which he wants to avoid, might be the better.

Who stands fast? Only the man whose final standard is not his reason, his principles, his conscience, his freedom, or his virtue, but who is ready to sacrifice all this when he is called to obedient and responsible action in faith and in exclusive allegiance to God…

Here Bonhoeffer analyses the nature of and some typical approaches to evil, finding none of the latter sufficient, whatever the virtue of their attempt, if they exclude resource to God – in Syria, of course, this will be Allah.

*****

6

6.

New window

7

7.

New window

… he [the German] could not see the need for free and responsible action, even in opposition to his task and his calling; in its place there appeared on the one hand an irresponsible lack of scruple, and on the other a self-tormenting punctiliousness that never led to action. Civil courage, in fact, can grow only out of the free responsibility of free men.

Here Bonhoeffer discusses, in essence, the German love for authority, but questions it when such “submissiveness and self-sacrifice could be exploited for evil ends”. We see, in Syria, SAA men running forward into fire carrying their national flag, their devotion unquestionable. But, as did the Germans once, they do not see the depths of the wickedness for which they sacrifice themselves; and maybe too, also like the Germans, they deal with what they do understand of it by throwing scruple to the wind, on the one hand, or being nitpickingly exact, on the other (the evidence suggests all Assad’s murders have been recorded carefully in lists, as occurred in Nazi Germany – if you bureaucratise death, you lance its sting, one could add… it becomes merely an item of record).

*****

8

8.

New window

9

9.

New window

As long as goodness is successful, we can afford the luxury of regarding it as having no ethical significance; it is when success is achieved by evil means that the problem arises.

The Assads have created health and educational services, built a dam and motorways and run a symphony orchestra. Must in themselves these be dismissed, discredited or even destroyed? Bonhoeffer argues here that the new generation must take responsibility for historical fact, not rail against it, and adds that “the ruler of history repeatedly brings good out of evil over the heads” of the makers of historical absolutes, such as, in Syria’s case, the existence of a hospital built by the régime.

*****

10

10.

New window

11

11.

New window

12

12.

New window

… we see that any violent display of power, whether political or religious, produces an outburst of folly in a large part of mankind; indeed, this seems actually to be a psychological and sociological law: the power of some needs the folly of the others.

In another translation of Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s “After 10 Years” the word “stupidity” is used, not “folly”, though I think “folly” is the better. This translation is from:

click

As the title suggests, the bulk of the book deals with letters and papers written after the author’s arrest in April 1943, unlike “After 10 Days”, which was written before, the original German title of the book “Widerstand und Ergebung: Briefe und Aufzeichnungen aus der Haft”. The copyright notices for this enlarged edition are dated 1953, 1967 and 1971. Bonhoeffer’s works, in their complete state, are assiduously kept off the free web. I obtained my copy of “After 10 Years” from a pre-purchase preview, access awkward and dependent on browser, and was then geoblocked from buying the complete Kindle book. The copy here is presented as, mainly, pictures in the hope that copyright crawlers will not see the text, deletion from Yalla Souriya’s WordPress maybe then demanded if they did. My attempt here to tie in Assadism in Syria with National Socialism in Germany requires, obviously, an unredacted copy of “After 10 Years”, if the reader is to make his own deductions. And I consider the subject sufficiently important, and the hiding of Bonhoeffer’s writings behind pay walls sufficiently excessive (and incompetently run), not to be unduly bothered by the minor breach of copyright which the pictures in this article may represent.

Returning now to the matter at hand and the text of “Of folly”, little further comment is required from me as Bonhoeffer paints a very exact picture of how power can corrupt the intelligence of the powerless and turn them, as a type of social herd, into fools “capable of any evil and at the same time incapable of seeing that it is evil”. This picture shows a pretty girl happy amongst the ruins of Syria:

girls-in-ruins-1021381573

Entrance of the Carlton Hotel, in the government controlled area of Aleppo, Syria, 17th December 2016., by Omar Sanadiki, Reuters

New window

These ladies were dolled up for the occasion, it would seem, pleased to pose and so demonstrate the sort of insentience Bonhoeffer describes – reminiscent of the habit in previous centuries of generals bringing their ladies, in full finery, to a hilltop to watch the battle – men being killed – below. Pure folly in each case, if for different reasons – the rush of something malign or violent, or both, and bigger than the commonplace, skewing crusty as well as pretty heads, maybe the common thread.

*****

13

13.

New window

We must learn to regard people less in the light of what they do or omit to do, and more in the light of what they suffer.

Bonhoeffer is fairly severe about fools (pictures 10-12 above) but now advances forgiveness. In a reconciled Syria, this quality will be required more than any other.

*****

14

14.

New window

15

15.

New window

The world is, in fact, so ordered that a basic respect for ultimate laws and human life is also the best means of self-preservation, and that these laws may be broken only on the odd occasion in case of brief necessity, whereas anyone who turns necessity into a principle, and in so doing establishes a law of his own alongside them, is inevitably bound, sooner or later, to suffer retribution.

I admit I find Bonhoeffer a touch abstruse in this submission. He was a pastor but also part of a plot to kill Hitler. Natural laws governing human behaviour should never be transgressed using the excuse of self-preservation, or else the transgressor ultimately weakens his ability to survive, defeating the object; but such laws may of necessity be broken, conditional upon the brevity of this act of fracture and the rapid restoration of normality. This condemns of course states of emergency which never end but permits assassination of a diabolical instrument! On this basis, the Assadian principle of shooting dead active, real but unarmed opponents over months then indiscriminately bombing areas harbouring their armed descendants does constitute “deliberate transgression of the divine law in the supposed interests of worldly self-preservation” and will have “exactly the opposite effect” of that intended. His actions will be judged in the here and now, the hardness of his heart in the hereafter, Bonhoeffer might suggest, if he were alive today. My own view is that Assad is his father’s child, more than merely biologically. He does not actually know what his actions amount to, or the nature of his heart, as, in his deepest subconscious, killing is a form of play, the victims nursery toys. Asma knows differently but, as mere wife, owns the luxury of unaccountability and thus can think the unthinkable, and convey those thoughts, as if she were still a schoolgirl in Acton – that is, with impunity. So, any actions consequent upon her thoughts are in fact divorced from her thinking, in her own eyes; and his actions are divorced from his heart as both are possessed – one in one hand, and the other in the other, like juggling balls – by his father’s ghost. So, as Bonhoeffer might infer, the two Assads, witlessly, will prove their own folly and defeat their own object as neither, in their respective prisons, has listened to God and thus got out. The blame though, maybe, is not theirs. Retribution may turn out to be their release, if cruel. 

*****

16

16.

New window

These words speak for themselves and should encourage those downhearted by the state of the revolution.

*****

17

17.

New window

Trust… can emerge only on the dark background of a necessary mistrust.

The law of opposites: light, to exist, depends on darkness. There have been signs of greater trust between opposition factions during the last year or so; the current pressures may now make this unavoidable, for those who survive to march on.

*****

18

18.

New window

19

19.

New window

Quality… means a return from the newspaper and the radio to the book.

Today this means a return from the cellphone and the TV to the newspaper and the radio! These remarks have little bearing, however, on Syria in 2016/7 per se though do prefigure aspects of our world today, especially media infatuation with celebrities – the “cult of the ‘star’”, as Bonhoeffer puts it.

*****

20

20.

New window

[Lack of wisdom] explains… insensibility to the sufferings of others; sympathy grows in proportion to the fear of approaching disaster.

Indifference to the horrors inculcated by the Syrian war, particularly the suffering caused by government use of heavy ordnance against civilian targets in rebel zones, to turn the population against the fighters, is one of the most sickening features of the West’s appraisal of the crisis, but only to be expected, as the war for a long time did not affect our daily lives. This changed with the influx of refugees, who however have been greeted instead not with indifference but simple stoniness: “You’re not wanted.” The one exception – which would please Bonhoeffer – has been Germany, in the person of Merkel, who knew the significance of her actions, taking into account her country’s past. In a sense she is a descendant of Bonhoeffer and his virtue. By coincidence, her father was also a pastor, though my guess is that Merkel was thinking beyond family and instead, well ahead of the public gaze, towards the redemption of Germany herself. Unfortunately, if the Syrian war is not halted, it will spread, continue to enlarge and will thus creep into European lives as something which threatens life and limb. There have been small beginnings of this, such as the recent visit by the Syrian Grand Mufti to Dublin, a propaganda slingshot, but still a slingshot. According to Bonhoeffer we will only start to care about the Syrian war if it becomes our war too. It would help, of course, if we had the wisdom to care about it now.

*****

21

21.

New window

The silence of spiritual suffering.

*****

22

22.

New window

It is not easy to be brave and keep [the] spirit alive, but it is imperative.

Encouragement to the  troops! If there is virtue in the Syrian revolution – and I believe myself that there is – its mission will prevail.

*****

23

23.

New window

Here Bonhoeffer qualifies wisdom, as it is wise to be pessimistic. Yet, he sees a narrow path of optimism, being a “will for the future” – determination not to give in.

*****

24

24.

New window

It would probably not be true to say that we welcome death… [Before we die] we should like to see something more of the meaning of our life’s broken fragments.

Being in active, militant (the plot with which Bonhoeffer was allied culminated in a failed bomb blast against Hilter in July 1944) opposition to Hitler was a very dangerous business, as it has generally been to oppose from a position of freedom Assad. One can sense from this piece how Bonhoeffer expected death, as do so many Syrian opposition fighters when interviewed: victory or death is the line, borne out by battlefield casualties. In Libya a fighter said, just outside Misurata, grinning from ear to ear, “We win or we die.” At the time, the Syrian armed struggle had barely started. But, those words from Libya have their echo in Syria, if more grimly, the opponent far stronger. For Bonhoeffer and his associates, the need for inward strength was maybe even more acute, as they had no territory, had to stay hidden. Bonhoeffer was still ostensibly free, when he wrote this. But, he does not sound like a free man.

*****

25

25.

New window

We have been silent witnesses of evil deeds; we have been drenched by many storms; we have learnt the arts of equivocation and pretence; experience has made us suspicious of others and kept us from being truthful and open; intolerable conflicts have worn us down and even made us cynical. Are we still of any use? What we shall need is not geniuses, or cynics, or misanthropes, or clever tacticians, but plain, honest, straightforward men. Will our inward power of resistance be strong enough, and our honesty with ourselves remorseless enough, for us to find our way back to simplicity and straightforwardness?

I have left the last words attached to these pictures of “After 10 Years” to Dietrich Bonhoeffer. He was hanged on 9th April 1945, less than a month before Hitler shot himself.

*****

Addendum

In this edition, a final paragraph is added, though it is not wholly clear when it was written or whether or not Bonhoeffer had written it for “After 10 Years” (but then maybe did not include it). Further, it is unfinished. It speaks directly from the soul of one who, together with his associates, has become numbered amongst the “outcast, the suspects, the maltreated, the powerless, the oppressed, the reviled”:

26

26.

End

Al-Kamoneh / Al-Kamoune / Kemmune (Turkish) / الكمونة IDP camp, Sarmada, Al-Dana subdistrict, Harem district, Idlib governorate – Syria.

IDP = Internally Displaced Person.

This camp (hereinafter Al-Kamoneh) is referred to in this video from TRT World published 22nd December:

This is the camp which was bombed or shelled on 5th May this year but is now receiving what appears to be a significant upgrade by Turkish-led operators.

The TRT report “earlier this week” mentioned in this clip is difficult to identify as the name “Kemmune” which the reporter uses here is not explicitly stated in any earlier video from TRT from that week, though there are other videos touching on the IDP subject and showing tents, etc.

In fact, detail on IDP camps in Idlib is very difficult to find, away from mainstream generalisations and imprecision. For this reason, I decided to find the Al-Kamoneh camp and commenced the hunt the day after the above TRT video was published, eventually finding the detail I required four days, and about 140 bookmarks, later.

Factual detail on these camps seems to reside almost entirely within the databases of an assorted medley of NGOs or monitoring agencies. Few possess reports from any agent on site. These groups appear to rely heavily on satellite imagery culled from sources more up to date than those available via regular online maps, such as Google. Thus, some IDP camps are not visible at all on the latter type of map, and Al-Kamoneh is one of them.

The name of this camp – if Al-Kamoneh is in fact its name – derives from the Arabic for cumin, thus:

الكمونة from كمون.

كمو are the common characters.

Another name, Ghita Al-Rahmeh, is also mentioned for the camp. However, whatever its name is, its location can be seen here:

al-kamoune-earth-screenshot2

Google 26th August 2014 image

Detail

(Please note the town of Sarmada is identified only in Arabic; it is the first conurbation across the plain north-west of “Main Damage”and is marked with a red dot just above its name.)

Marked on that image are the site of the main 5th May strike and the top left and bottom right corners of this:al-kamoneh-pdf-detail

Detail

Source

To see the camp’s location on the 2014 map, use:

Google Maps.

The point where the thin dark line running north-east meets, and forms a right angle with, a similar line running south-east marks the south-east corner of the main cluster of the camp, though in 2014 – as can be seen – the whole area of the current Al-Kamoneh camp was just empty hillside.

Other, older camps around Sarmada and beyond in Al-Dana subdistrict can be checked using the coordinates in this list (the six containing the word Sarmada are also shown on the Google Earth image at the top of this post, in addition to the unlisted Al-Kamoneh camp, to give context):

MS Word download.

Original source for that list was an .xlsx document “Syria_IDPSites_2016EarlyJan_HIU_USDoS” created on 14th January this year by the Humanitarian Information Unit of the Office of the Geographer and Global Issues, U.S. Department of State – it does not, as implied, contain detail on the Al-Kamoneh camp; none of the coordinates are far enough south. The camp was probably coming into being during the months prior to the 5th May attack, but not as early an January. Or, the department’s sources hadn’t noticed it in its beginnings.

During my enquiries, it became clear to me that most of Idlib and western Aleppo is host to, essentially, homeless people, some 800,000 or more of them, around 300,000 living with local families, another 300,000 or so mainly in camps or, otherwise, with unknown whereabouts, about 50,000 “under trees” and so on – and this was before the Aleppo East evacuation. As already stated, it is clear there is no central authority coordinating management of these displaced persons, the data itself disparate and scattered (the foregoing figures are from Reach). If further conflict is added to this expanse of human suffering and misery, the already downtrodden and bereft will find that their afflictions are insufficient, as they must now be murdered in bulk, to make good. And much of this will not be seen or monitored, in the empty and exposed places where some of these people live.

Hopefully, therefore, Turkey will continue to push forcefully ahead with its humanitarian effort, west of Aleppo, as its presence in this wise in Syria is a deterrent. As regards its northern, military advance mixed signals and manoeuvres appear currently to be emerging, from that state, as is to be expected with talks in Kazakhstan in the offing. Just under two weeks ago, 27th December had been billed for a tripartite meeting in Moscow, the participants Russia, Turkey and Iran, to discuss achieving an overall ceasefire throughout Syria. However, that meeting occurred on the the 20th. The next, in Kazakhstan, may include Assad. If so, this is not necessarily a meeting which will produce the aforementioned ceasefire, but a template for reconfigured military operations, as, when push becomes shove, Turkey will not abide the survival of Assad. She, or at any rate Erdogan, knows him too well.